Teaching Critically About Lewis and Clark: A Comprehensive Guide for Educators

The Lewis and Clark Expedition holds a prominent place in American history and collective consciousness. For generations, students have learned about the explorers' epic journey across the uncharted West. However, in recent years, scholars have begun to critically examine the expedition's legacy, considering its impact on Native American tribes, the environment, and the shaping of American expansionism.

Teaching about Lewis and Clark requires a balanced approach that acknowledges both the expedition's historical significance and its complexities. This article provides educators with a comprehensive guide to teaching critically about Lewis and Clark, addressing key historical issues, resources, and strategies for engaging students in meaningful discussions.

Before embarking on a critical exploration of the Lewis and Clark Expedition, it is crucial to establish a foundational understanding of the historical context that shaped it. The expedition took place during a period of westward expansion when the United States was eager to assert its dominance over the vast territories of the West. The Louisiana Free Download of 1803 gave the United States control of a vast region known as the Louisiana Territory, which extended from the Mississippi River to the Rocky Mountains.

Teaching Critically About Lewis and Clark: Challenging Dominant Narratives in K–12 Curriculum

by Diana K. Schwam

4.6 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	23799 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	209 pages
Paperback	:	198 pages
Item Weight	:	1.04 pounds
Dimensions	:	8.5 x 0.45 x 11 inches
Screen Reader	:	Supported

FREE

President Thomas Jefferson commissioned the Lewis and Clark Expedition to explore the newly acquired territory, establish trading relationships with Native American tribes, and find a water route to the Pacific Ocean. The expedition consisted of approximately 40 men, including Meriwether Lewis, William Clark, and Sacagawea, a Native American woman who served as a guide and interpreter.

The expedition set out from St. Louis, Missouri, in May 1804. Traveling by boat and on foot, they encountered diverse Native American cultures, explored the uncharted wilderness, and documented the flora and fauna they encountered. The expedition reached the Pacific Ocean in November 1805, where they wintered at Fort Clatsop. They returned to St. Louis in September 1806, after completing their 8,000-mile journey.

While the Lewis and Clark Expedition is often celebrated for its scientific discoveries and contributions to American history, contemporary scholarship has raised important critical perspectives that challenge traditional narratives. These perspectives offer valuable insights into the expedition's impact on Native American tribes, the environment, and the development of American expansionism.

The Lewis and Clark Expedition had a profound impact on the Native American tribes they encountered. The expedition's intrusion into Native American territories disrupted traditional ways of life, introduced diseases, and contributed to intertribal conflicts. The explorers often relied on Native American guides, interpreters, and provisions, yet they often failed to respect Native American sovereignty or compensate them fairly for their assistance.

The Lewis and Clark Expedition had a significant impact on the environment of the West. The expedition's exploration of uncharted territories led to the of invasive species, such as the zebra mussel, which disrupted the balance of ecosystems. Additionally, the expedition's hunting practices depleted wildlife populations and contributed to the displacement of Native American tribes that relied on these resources.

The Lewis and Clark Expedition played a role in shaping American expansionism. The exploration and mapping of the Louisiana Territory provided the United States with valuable information that aided in its acquisition of new land and the displacement of Native American tribes. The expedition's reports on the abundance of natural resources and the strategic importance of waterways influenced American expansionist policies.

There are a wealth of resources available to educators who wish to teach critically about Lewis and Clark. These resources provide historical documents, lesson plans, and multimedia materials that can enhance student understanding and promote critical thinking.

Primary sources offer students the opportunity to engage with firsthand accounts of the Lewis and Clark Expedition. These sources include:

• Lewis and Clark journals: The journals kept by Meriwether Lewis and William Clark provide a detailed record of the expedition's daily activities, encounters with Native Americans, and scientific observations.
• Sacagawea's story: Sacagawea, a Shoshone woman, played a vital role in the expedition as a guide and interpreter. Her story offers insights into the Native American experience and the challenges faced by women in the early 19th century.
• Native American perspectives: Contemporary scholars have compiled accounts and oral histories from Native American tribes that provide diverse perspectives on the expedition's impact.

Educators can find a variety of lesson plans that incorporate critical perspectives on the Lewis and Clark Expedition. These lesson plans provide engaging activities, discussion questions, and resources to facilitate student learning.

• Exploring the Impact on Native Americans: This lesson plan explores the complex relationship between the Lewis and Clark Expedition and the Native American tribes it encountered. Students analyze primary sources and engage in discussions about the expedition's impact on Native American sovereignty, culture, and environment.
• Examining the Environmental Legacy: This lesson plan investigates the expedition's impact on the environment of the West. Students examine scientific data and engage in discussions about the of invasive species, the depletion of wildlife populations, and the long-term consequences of the expedition's exploration.
• Critically Analyzing American Expansionism: This lesson plan examines the role of the Lewis and Clark Expedition in shaping American expansionist policies. Students analyze historical documents and maps to understand the expedition's impact on land acquisition, Native American displacement, and the development of westward expansionism.

Multimedia materials can make learning about Lewis and Clark more engaging and accessible for students. These materials include:

• Documentaries: Several documentaries have been produced that explore different aspects of the Lewis and Clark Expedition. These documentaries provide a visually rich and informative overview of the expedition's history and legacy.
• Interactive maps: Interactive maps allow students to trace the route of the expedition, explore the geography of the West, and learn about the Native American tribes they encountered.
• Virtual field trips: Virtual field trips provide students with the opportunity to visit historical sites associated with the Lewis and Clark Expedition, such as Fort Clatsop and the Missouri River.

To foster critical thinking and promote meaningful student engagement, educators can employ various discussion strategies when teaching about Lewis and Clark. These strategies include:

Socratic seminars encourage students to engage in thoughtful and rigorous discussions by posing open-ended questions and facilitating student dialogue. By questioning each other's assumptions and perspectives, students develop critical thinking skills and deepen their understanding of complex historical issues.

Jigsaw activities divide students into groups and assign each group a different aspect of the Lewis and Clark Expedition to research and present to the class. This approach allows students to become experts on specific topics and contribute their knowledge to a comprehensive understanding of the expedition.

Role-playing and simulations allow students to step into the shoes of historical figures and experience the events of the Lewis and Clark Expedition firsthand. These activities foster empathy, enhance historical understanding, and promote critical analysis.

Teaching critically about Lewis and Clark requires educators to navigate complex historical issues and engage students in meaningful discussions. By incorporating critical perspectives, utilizing diverse resources, and employing effective discussion strategies, educators can empower students to understand the expedition's historical significance while recognizing its complexities and impact on Native Americans, the environment, and American expansionism.

Through critical examination, we can challenge traditional narratives, foster historical empathy, and encourage students to become informed and engaged citizens who actively participate in shaping the future.

Teaching Critically About Lewis and Clark: Challenging Dominant Narratives in K–12 Curriculum

by Diana K. Schwam

4.6 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	23799 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	209 pages
Paperback	:	198 pages
Item Weight	:	1.04 pounds
Dimensions	:	8.5 x 0.45 x 11 inches
Screen Reader	:	Supported

FREE